It used to be real wine

[Note: Feel free to skip this, since it's a run down on the service I went to today and isn't for everyone.]

I went to a Presbyterian service this morning, my first. Wasn't sure I would go to any service (and how long am I going to church-troll anyway?), but it was conveniently located across from McDonald's (small coffee with double cream plus carrot muffin for $1.45). I had toyed with the idea of going there last weekend, but had skipped it.

It's a lovely old church, with the congregation sitting in a half-circle.
Similar to the first United church I went to several weeks ago.
All the women were giving little candles in honour of Mother's Day:
As for the service itself, it was Communion, which apparently isn't given often. Now, I've not taken Communion in decades, but my experience then and even recently at the Anglican churches, is that you go up to the altar. In this instance the pieces of bread and rice crackers were passed around on platters, no one got up. Ditto for the "wine," which was some sort of juice, presumably cranberry. It was passed around in tiny single tumblers, maybe thimble sized, on special platters.

The last time I took Communion it was real wine or sherry or whatever it was that they used. And real Communion wafers too, for that matter.

The choir, who all had been in their stalls above the altar at the very beginning of the service, sang their opening hymn and then joined the congregation, so they could take Communion too. I didn't quite understand why they couldn't just return to their proper places afterward, given that the Communion was early in the service, but frankly, I couldn't hear them sing. They faced the altar for the duration of the service, not us. It didn't make any sense to me. (I should note that their organist was pretty darned impressive, though. As were those organ pipes!)

The minister had a passionate sermon about accepting diversity in the way we worship "god," which was great, but prior to that was very apologetic about us singing one hymn in the Presbyterian hymnal that refers to god as female (and male). That bothered me greatly, that he felt he should apologize for including that hymn in the service. I happen to think that whatever "god" is, it's beyond gender, beyond our petty, limited human definitions.

Overall, I'd have to say that this Presbyterian service fell somewhere between Anglican and United. Not as structured and formal as the Anglican, not as informal as the United, and definitely not joyful and celebratory like the United services, either. I'm not sorry I went--I got to peek inside after all--but I can't imagine returning. Isn't there a church around here that really rocks, without being over-the-top?

So, next week? Beats me!

Comments

Angel Simba said…
We actually attend a Presbyterian church, yet I grew up in the Anglican church, so I can identify with some of your comparisons. Though our choir stay in the choir stalls behind the pulpit, and get served their communion there. We also have the grape juice and bread passed to us where we sit. In the Presbyterian church my daughter attends, they walk up for it, and have a choice of juice or wine. So there is quite a lot of variation by individual Presbyterian churches.
Good luck in your search for a church that suits you well.
Our particular church has a big emphasis on the music, has multiple childrens' choirs as well as the adult one. The organist also plays the piano - there is a grand piano in the sanctuary too. The 4 year old cherub choir did the sweetest series of short songs today for Mother's day. They were adorable.

The Mom
Anonymous said…
I attended a funeral for a friend a few years ago at a Presbyterian church and loved the Pastor's eulogy so I went there for Easter service the next Spring ( I also work with the pastor's wife). I enjoyed it. If I wasn't a Mormon I would probably be a Presbyterian. Or Catholic, which I grew up as.

I went to an Anglican church when I lived in Florida. It reminded me of the Episcopalian church
Old Kitty said…
I am so ignorant - I thought only Catholics take communion (something to do with the actual belief that the wine truly turns into Jesus's blood during the blessing or something like that, I think!!!) but now you've totally enlightened me!! Thank you!!

BUT!!! I have never heard of a choir with their backs to their parishoners!!! Did I spell that word right, there's a big red line underneath it! LOL! Anyway!! That's a weird way to engage your audience - then again maybe they were too scared to sing about the genderless Goddess (hah!! Goddess, why not!!Ahem!)

I do hope you get to visit another church/denomination next Sunday - I think your Sunday series of attending different services is really unique - so a basis for a book!!! I'm being serious!!! Your pics are fab and your experiences are a great read!!! And this is me about to leave to go and see Star Trek!! Yay!!

It's Monday morning now and it's grey and drizzly!! Take care
x
John Bellen said…
It sounds like that church has been struck pretty hard by political correctness. Why not wine? One never receives more than a sip of it anyway; it's not going hurt anyone at that amount. And I figure that since the Bible refers to God as He, that's the way it should be left. I don't really care for people changing the bits that don't suit them. But I agree in that since God is everything He's female as well as male - and is neither, too. You can do that when you're God, I imagine.
ANGEL ABBYGRACE said…
Just love the beauty of the stained glass windows.
Saku said…
I grew up Anglican, started attending the Alliance church as a young adult, and eventually quit attending on a regular basis when my second child was born.

I hope you find a service that suits you or better yet a congregation that is welcoming.

In the meantime, it sounds like a great plan to test drive the various locations.